In 1994, President George Rupp appointed Lloyd Executive Vice President for Administration. She stayed on in the position under Lee Bollinger, though in January of 2003 she was reassigned to the newly created position of EVP for Government and Community Affairs, roughly halving her previous responsibilities. Robert Kasdin, whom Bollinger had brought with him from the University of Michigan and installed in the newly created post of Senior EVP, took over the non-community related responsibilities of Lloyd's former position. Many outside observers, particularly in the community, claimed that Lloyd was being demoted and had been systematically left out of Bollinger's 'inner-circle' of decision makers, in stark contrast with her role under Rupp.
Lloyd left her position in the summer of 2004. At the time Bollinger stated that no replacement would be sought and that the government and community affairs portfolio would be assigned to Loretta Ucelli, who had been hired just a few months before as the new EVP Communications and External Relations. However, a string of PR flaps took their toll, and Maxine Griffith was hired in Summer of 2005 to fill the post of VP Government and Community Affairs and report to Ucelli. Ucelli left Columbia within a month and Griffith was promoted to EVP and reports directly to Bollinger.
- On the Heights, A Chill Wind Begins to Blow, NY Times, 14 September 2003
- Neighbors Mourn Loss Of Vice Pres. Emily Lloyd, Columbia Spectator, 21 September 2004.
- Bollinger Appoints Lloyd Community Affairs VP, Columbia Spectator, January 27, 2003
- President Bollinger Names Emily Lloyd Executive Vice President for Government and Community Affairs, Columbia News, January 24, 2003
- Lloyd Leaves Columbia, Columbia Spectator, June 15, 2004
- Maxine Griffith Named Vice President for Government and Community Affairs, Columbia News, July 13, 2005
- A New Public Face: Ucelli Away as Griffith Steps Up, Columbia Spectator, August 5, 2005